Skip to content
Island Gypsy Cafe — Naples, Florida™

Guides

Waterfront Seafood on the Isles of Capri: Your Guide to Island Gypsy Cafe

Some places just feel like Southwest Florida. Tucked on the Capri Marina along Tarpon Bay, Island Gypsy Café & Marina Bar has been that kind of spot for locals, visitors, and boaters since we opened our doors in 2011. If you're looking for seafood on the water in Naples, or a laid back lunch between Marco Island and downtown, here's everything you need to know before you come hungry.

Where to Find Us on the Isles of Capri

Island Gypsy sits at 292 Capri Blvd, Naples, FL 34113, right on the Capri Marina in the Isles of Capri. It's a marina style restaurant with a casual, relaxed feel, an oversized bar, and an abundance of waterfront seating with idyllic bayside views. Grab a table outside, order something tropical, and enjoy some serious boat gazing while you wait for your food.

We're open every day:

That makes us an easy call for a long lunch, an afternoon drink by the water, or dinner as the day winds down. You can get directions and contact details here, call us at (239) 394-1111, or book a table online.

Seafood Sourced Mainly From Florida Waters

Everett Fromm, Chef at Island Gypsy Cafe

Chef Everett Fromm runs the kitchen, and his lineup leans on seafood sourced mainly from Florida waters. Everett first cooked at Island Gypsy, spent time leading the kitchen at our sister restaurant, and is now back where he started on the Isles of Capri. His approach is all about balance: mild vegetables, a touch of acidity, and a light sauce that lets the natural sweetness of the fish come through.

What to order if it's your first visit

You can't go wrong with the classics. A few favorites from the full menu:

Coastal coconut shrimp with greens and lemonFried calamari with cherry peppers, lemon and chili sauce

Bigger plates for supper

If you're settling in for dinner, look at the supper section. Jerry's Island Grouper comes grilled with a mandarin pineapple chili reduction and mango salsa. The Macadamia Nut Mahi Mahi gets a panko macadamia crust and a rum pineapple beurre blanc. Chef Everett has a soft spot for hogfish ("I love hogfish due to their beauty and mild flavor," he says), so the Yucatán Hogfish is worth a look too. Feeling indecisive? The Gypsy Fried Seafood Basket brings fried haddock, North Atlantic scallops, and jumbo shrimp together on one plate.

Not everyone at the table wants seafood, and that's fine. There are burgers, the Captiva Chicken Sandwich, salads, baby back ribs slow cooked in Dr. Pepper, and pasta. Ask your server about gluten free options.

Save room for dessert. The "Island Gypsy" Famous Carrot Cake and the Marco Island Key Lime Pie are both made for sharing.

Gypsy Tropical Impairments: Drinks at the Marina Bar

Lineup of frozen cocktails with J.F. Haden's liqueurs at the marina

Our marina bar is half the fun. The "Gypsy Tropical Impairments" list is exactly what it sounds like: rum forward, fruity, and built for a warm afternoon on the water. Try the Gypsy Punch, the Crazy Cuban (a favorite of our CEO and GM, Nick Alajajian), or a classic Rum Runner. There are frozen drinks, mocktails, wine, and beer too, so there's something for everyone at the table. See the drink menu for the full list.

The Legend Behind the Name

Dessert with whipped cream and mint on the deck rail over the water

Every visitor asks about the boat stern at our entrance, so here's the short version. The Island Gypsy was a custom built, 63 foot sport fishing yacht owned and crewed by Isles of Capri residents. She made adventure trips to places like the Bahamas, the Keys, the Tortugas, and Havana, and she and her crew became local legends.

On October 24, 2005, Hurricane Wilma hit while she was docked on the Isles of Capri. The storm battered her badly, and she was eventually scuttled and taken away in pieces, all except one. The entire 20 foot stern section was saved, and it's now proudly on display at the entrance of Island Gypsy Cafe. You can read the full Legend of the Island Gypsy and meet the crew on our Story page.

Tips for Visiting Island Gypsy

Frequently Asked Questions

Where is Island Gypsy Cafe located?

We're at 292 Capri Blvd, Naples, FL 34113, on the Capri Marina in the Isles of Capri, overlooking Tarpon Bay.

What are Island Gypsy's hours?

We're open daily. Monday to Thursday, 11 AM to 9 PM. Friday to Sunday, 11 AM to 10 PM.

Does Island Gypsy take reservations?

Yes. You can book a table online through our website or call (239) 394-1111.

What is Island Gypsy known for?

Fresh seafood sourced mainly from Florida waters, like our Coastal Coconut Shrimp and grouper sandwich, plus tropical drinks, waterfront seating, and the stern of the original Island Gypsy yacht at our entrance.

Are there options for people who don't eat seafood?

Yes. The menu includes burgers, chicken sandwiches, salads, ribs, and pasta. Please ask your server about gluten free options.

Come Hungry, Stay for the View

Whether you're a Naples local, staying on Marco Island, or out on the water for the day, Island Gypsy is ready with fresh seafood, cold tropical drinks, and plenty of waterfront seating. Take a look at the menu, then come see us on the Isles of Capri. Locally World Famous™ since 2011.