Menus

• Peel & Eat Shrimp

  1/2 lb $15 / 1 lb $28

  Gulf Shrimp / Old Bay & Citrus Boiled

• Coastal Coconut Shrimp

  $18

  Jumbo Shrimp / Hand Breaded / Mango Horseradish Marmalade

• “Gator Nicks” Chicken Wings

  $16

  Sauce Options - Buffalo / Hot / Honey Teriyaki / Gypsy Sauce / Sweet Thai Chili / Coconut Curry

• PEI Mussels

  $18

  Chorizo / White Wine / Garlic Butter / Roasted Tomatoes / Herb Focaccia

  Add Fra Diavolo - $2

• Onion Rings

  $13

  Fresh Cut Daily / Hand Battered / Pineapple Chipotle Aioli

• Fried Calamari

  $18

  Cherry Peppers / Lemon / Florida Orange Chili

• Spiced Tuna Tataki

  $18

  Scallion / Sesame / Ginger / Wasabi Aioli / Crispy Wonton Hay

• Smoked Fish Dip

  $18

  Smoked Mahi-Mahi / Pickled Jalapeños / Cherry Peppers / Gherkin Pickles / Everything Flatbread Crackers

• Bahama Mama Black Bean Dip

  $11

  Black Bean / Pico De Gallo / Citrus Sour Cream / Tortilla Chips

• Lump Crab Cakes

  $24

  Lump Crab / Jicama Slaw / Whole Grain Mustard / Sweet Thai

• Harry’s Isles of Capri Cheeseburger

  $20

  Ground Chuck & Brisket Blended Burger / Toasted Brioche Bun / LTO / Bacon Shallot Jam / White Cheddar / Crispy Fries

• Grammy Mary’s Fried Fish Sandwich

  $21

  Fried Haddock / Brioche Bun / Bibb Lettuce / Tomato / Tartar / Creamy Slaw / Crispy Fries

• Caribbean Fish Tacos

  $19

  Caribbean Jerk Seasoned Mahi-Mahi / Pineapple Chipotle Aioli / Black Bean Corn Salsa / Jicama Slaw / Housemade Chips

• BBQ Chicken Quesadilla

  $16

  Seasoned Chicken / BBQ / Pepperjack Cheese / Black Bean Corn Salsa / Sour Cream / Tomato Salsa

• New England Lobster Roll

  $30

  Maine Lobster / N.E. Style Challah Roll / Lemon Chive Aioli / Bibb Lettuce / Housemade Chips

• Braised Beef Short Rib Sliders

  $27

  Braised Beef / Challah Roll / Bacon Shallot Jam / Horseradish Crema

• Mahi-Mahi Sandwich

  $23

  Fresh Mahi-Mahi / Kaiser Bun / Bibb Lettuce / Tomato / Tartar / Creamy Slaw / Crispy Fries

  Served Grilled, Blackened, or Fried

• Captiva Chicken Sandwich

  $18

  Apple Cider Brined / Brioche Bun / Bacon / Sriracha Aioli / White Cheddar / Grilled Pineapple / LTO / Crispy Fries

• “Locally World Famous™” Grouper Sandwich

  $26

  Fresh Gulf Grouper / Kaiser Bun / Bibb Lettuce / Tomato / Tartar / Creamy Slaw / Crispy Fries

  Served Grilled, Blackened, or Fried

• Lobster “N”euben

  $31

  Maine Lobster / Grilled Marble Rye / Lemon Chive Aioli / Swiss Cheese / Creamy Slaw / Crispy Fries

• “Wick’d Pissah” Cape Cod Clam Chowda “The Best”

  Cup $8

Enhancements - Chicken $11 / Shrimp $13 / Mahi Mahi $15 / Grouper $17 / Lobster Salad $23

• Gypsy House Salad

  $13

  Mixed Greens / Blue Cheese Crumble / Mandarin Oranges / Grape Tomatoes / Toasted Macadamia Nuts / Pickled Red Onion / Key Lime Honey Vinaigrette

• Classic Caesar Salad

  $11

  Romaine / Shaved Parmesan / Homemade Croutons

• Iceberg Wedge Salad

  $11

  Blue Cheese Dressing / Tomato / Applewood Smoked Bacon / Blue Cheese Crumble

• Watermelon Feta Rocket Salad

  $16

  Watermelon / Rocket Lettuce / Cucumber / Feta / Candied Walnuts / Balsamic Dressing

• Wicked Tuna Wonton Salad

  $20

  Spiced Ahi Tuna / Mixed Greens / Mandarin Oranges / Cucumbers / Tomato / Wasabi Aioli / Sweet Thai Chili / Sesame Ginger Dressing / Wonton Crisp

• Fandango Mango Chicken Salad

  $19

  Grilled Chicken Breast / Mixed Greens / Fresh Mango / Hearts of Palm / Candied Walnuts / Radish Sprouts / Key Lime Honey Vinaigrette / Curry Mayo Drizzle

• Calypso Chicken Chopped Salad

  $19

  Grilled Chicken Breast / Chopped Lettuce / Applewood Bacon / Granny Smith Apples / Sweet Corn / Tomato / Blue Cheese Crumble / Homemade Ranch

• Jerry’s Island Grouper

  $39

  Florida Grilled Grouper / Mandarin Pineapple Chili Reduction / Mango Salsa / Blistered Asparagus / Cilantro Rice

• Shrimp & Scallop Pasta

  $29

  Sautéed Shrimp & Scallops / Linguine Pasta / Creamy Garlic Parmesan Sauce / Mushrooms / Tomato / Spinach / Herb Focaccia

• Sweet Baby Back Ribs

  $25

  Slow Cooked in Dr. Pepper / Full Rack / Creamy Slaw / Crispy Fries

• Lobster & Shrimp “Mac & Cheese”

  $30

  Maine Lobster / Shrimp / Pepperjack & Smoked Gouda Cheese / Smoked Bacon / Cavatappi Pasta / Herb Crumble

• Yucatán Hogfish

  $39

  Hogfish / Blistered Asparagus / Mango Ginger Butter Reduction / Papaya Mint Relish / Cilantro Rice

• Gypsy Fried Seafood Basket

  $30

  Fried Haddock / North Atlantic Scallops / Jumbo Shrimp / Cocktail / Tartar / Creamy Slaw / Crispy Fries

• Fried Shrimp Basket

  $27

  Eight Jumbo Fried Shrimp / Cocktail / Tartar / Creamy Slaw / Crispy Fries

• Lovers Key Primavera

  $21

  Linguine Pasta / Grape Tomatoes / Asparagus / Spinach / Basil Pesto / Herb Focaccia

• Macadamia Nut Mahi-Mahi

  $34

  Panko Macadamia Nut Crust / Blistered Asparagus / Myer Rum Pineapple Beurre Blanc / Caramelized Pineapple Relish / Cilantro Rice

• Coconut Curry Chicken

  $25

  Crispy Half Chicken / Asparagus / Coconut Curry Sauce / Cilantro Rice

• “Island Gypsy” Famous Carrot Cake (Table Share)

  $15

  Candied Walnuts / Caramel

• Towering Chocolate Cake (Table Share)

  $14

  Chocolate Syrup / Whipped Cream / Strawberries

• Marco Island Key Lime Pie

  $14

  Graham Cracker Crust / Whipped Cream

• Pina Colada Cheesecake

  $13

  Caramel Drizzle / Whipped Cream

• Gypsy Punch

  Light Rum / Dark Rum / Tropical Blend of Schnapps / Blackberry Brandy / Fruit Juices

• Crazy Cuban

  Light Rum / Coconut Rum / 99 Banana / Pineapple Juice / Dark Rum Floater

• Rum Runner

  Light Rum / Dark Rum / Creme De Banana / Blackberry Brandy / Orange Juice / Pineapple Juice / 151 Rum Floater

• Tipsy Gypsy Smash

  Twin P Bourbon / J.F. Haden's Mango Liqueur / Strawberry Puree / Lime Juice / Simple Syrup / Topped with Ginger Beer

• Capri Paloma

  Casa Loco Blanco / Ruby Red Grapefruit / Paloma Mix / Agave

• Strawberry Lemonade

  Lemon Vodka / Muddled Lemons / Strawberry Puree / Topped with Lemonade

• J.F. Haden’s Orange Crush

  Orange Vodka / J.F. Haden's Orange Liqueur / Muddled Oranges / Orange Juice / Topped with Ginger Ale

• Original Gypsy Mai Tai

  Light Rum / Dark Rum / Cointreau / Orgeat / Pineapple & Lime Juice

• Spicy Watermelon Margarita

  Ghost Tequila / Cointreau / Sour Mix / Watermelon Puree / Tajin Rim

• Red Tide

  Tito’s Vodka / Coconut Rum / Pineapple Juice / Cranberry Juice / Swedish Fish Floaters

• Espresso Mudslide

  Vanilla Vodka / J.F. Haden's Espresso Liqueur / Frangelico / Kahlua / Ice Cream Mix / Coco Lopez / Chocolate Swirl / Topped with Whipped Cream

• Passions Paradise

  J.F. Haden's Mango / Vanilla Vodka / Ice Cream Mix / Coco López / Passion Fruit Puree

• Orange Creamsicle Colada

  Orange Vodka / J.F. Haden's Orange Liqueur / Orange Juice / Coco Lopez / Ice Cream Mix / Topped with Whipped Cream

• Key Lime Colada

  Orange Vodka / J.F. Haden’s Key Lime Liqueur / Pineapple Juice / Coco Lopez

• Capri Sunset Daiquiri

  Raspberry Rum / J.F. Haden’s Citrus Liqueur / Raspberry & Mango Puree / Sour Mix

• Banana Boat Colada

  Fresh Bananas / Irish cream / Creme De Banana / Coco Lopez / Topped with Whipped Cream & a Kahlua Drizzle

• Raspberry No-Jito

  Raspberry Puree / Muddled Mint & Limes / Topped with Lemon-Lime Soda

• Sparkling Paloma

  Ruby Red Grapefruit & Lime Juice / Agave / Sparkling Water

• Carribean Punch

  Orange Juice / Lime & Pineapple Juice / Orgeat / Grenadine

• Strawberry No-Garita

  Strawberry Puree / Lime Juice / Sour Mix / Topped with Lemon-Lime Soda

Glass / Bottle

• Chardonnay — Copper Ridge (CAL)

  $7

• Chardonnay — Kendall Jackson (CAL)

  $10 / BTL $38

• Chardonnay — Sonoma Cutrer (CAL)

  $12 / BTL $45

• Pinot Grigio — Copper Ridge (CAL)

  $7

• Pinot Grigio — Sterling (CAL)

  $9 / BTL $34

• Sauvignon Blanc — Oyster Bay (NZ)

  $8 / BTL $28

• Sauvignon Blanc — Stoneleigh (NZ)

  $13.75 / BTL $49

• House Bubbles — Champagne Splits

  $7

• Copper Ridge White Zin (CAL)

  $7

• Whispering Angel “The Beach” Rosé

  $10 / BTL $38

• Cabernet — Copper Ridge (CAL)

  $7

• Cabernet — Sterling (CAL)

  $9.50 / BTL $37

• Pinot Noir — Coastal Vines (CAL)

  $7 / BTL $24

• Pinot Noir — Portlandia (Oregon)

  $10 / BTL $37

• Pinot Noir — Meiomi (CAL)

  BTL $50

• Merlot — Copper Ridge (CAL)

  $7

• Merlot — Maddalena (CAL)

  $35

• Drafts

  Bud Light / Turtle Season / Kona Longboard / Kona Big Wave / Islamorada Channel Marker / Gypsy Feature Tap

• Bottles / Cans

  Bud / Bud Light / Coors Light / Michelob Ultra / Miller Lite / Heineken / Yuengling / Stella Artois / Corona Extra / Corona Lite / Corona Premiere / Modelo / Shock Top / High 5 (IPA) / Outlaw Light / Gator Nates Whomp Whomp / EFC Gator Bait / Stella N.A. / High Noon (Variety) / Nutrls / Surfsides